Genocide is Justice?

Psalm 9:7-8

But the LORD sits enthroned forever;
he has established his throne for justice,
and he judges the world with righteousness;
he judges the peoples with uprightness.

...............

One of the most common objections to the Christian faith is that the God of the Bible is a homicidal maniac. He is called Jealous. He is narcissistic and deranged, bent on destruction of all who dare not bow down to Him. In this common misconception, we see how the world would consider Christian faith to be petty at best, if not completely foolish.

Indeed, one of the more troubling realities of God's story in Scripture is the Canaanite Genocide described in the book of Joshua, which is also prescribed by God in various passages of Exodus and Deuteronomy. God commanded the Israelites to conduct a kind of "ethnic cleansing," so they say. Men, women, children, and livestock were all "given over to destruction," as entire nations were brought to nothing so that God's people could inherit the promised land of Canaan. This is troubling no matter what you believe about God.

While I could explain away this genocide as some have tried to do, I cannot give an easy answer. The fast answer would be to say that we live in a fallen world which deserves to be utterly destroyed. It is only the grace of God that any of us is spared the destruction that the Canaanites received. But, at the end of that explanation, most people are still left feeling like God is a little harsh. Could mankind's sin really merit that kind of response? I thought God was merciful and kind, one might say.

Well, Psalm 9 gives us a window into the judgment of God that may be helpful in this debate. Verses 7 and 8 make the bold assertion that God is indeed just and that all of His judgments are righteous and upright. We have no problem with his justice when we see it benefiting the oppressed and afflicted (as described in verses 3-4, 9-10, 12, 13-14, and 18). But, we begin to cringe when we learn that God's justice also involves the destruction of the wicked oppressors (as described in verses 5-6, 12, 15-16, and 19-20). What we must realize is that God's redemption of the afflicted and His punishment of the wicked are two sides of the same coin. Truly, judgment means a separation of two camps of people (see the Parable of the Sheep and Goats in Matt. 25:31ff).

While I plan on saying more about the Canaanite genocide in future blogs, it is important to note at this point that the Psalmist is not stricken in his conscience about God's wrath in the ways that we are today. David does not see God's judgment and begin to doubt His goodness. Rather, He sees a God who is rescuing the afflicted, bringing just retribution on the heads of the wicked (9:15), and doing it all out of the vast wealth of His uprightness and integrity.